Chapter 7: Designs with Variation in Treatment Dose
Overview
Dataset: Pierce & Schott (2016) — pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta (Stata), pierce_schott_didtextbook.RData (R), pierce_schott_didtextbook.parquet (Python) (103 industries, 22 variables)
This chapter applies the Heterogeneous Adoption Design (HAD) framework to study how China’s permanent normal trade relations (PNTR) status affected US manufacturing employment. The key feature: treatment is continuous (the NTR gap, ranging from 0.02 to 0.64), not binary. All 103 US industries are “treated” — there are no pure control groups, but industries with near-zero NTR gaps serve as quasi-stayers.
Packages used:
| Task | Stata | R | Python |
|---|---|---|---|
| OLS + HC2 SE | reg, vce(hc2) |
sandwich + lmtest |
statsmodels (HC2) |
| Weight decomposition | twowayfeweights (SSC) |
TwoWayFEWeights (CRAN) |
Not available for fdTR |
| F-test | test (built-in) |
car::linearHypothesis |
scipy + f_test |
| HAD event-study | did_had (SSC) + nprobust (GitHub) + gtools (SSC) |
DIDHAD (GitHub) + nprobust (CRAN) |
did-had (PyPI) |
CQ#36: TWFE Regressions
Regress \(\Delta_{2000}^t Y_g\) on \(D_g\) (NTR gap) for \(t \in \{2001, 2002, 2004, 2005\}\), with HC2 standard errors.
copy "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta" "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", replace
use "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", clear
reg delta2001 ntrgap, vce(hc2 indusid, dfadjust)
reg delta2002 ntrgap, vce(hc2 indusid, dfadjust)
reg delta2004 ntrgap, vce(hc2 indusid, dfadjust)
reg delta2005 ntrgap, vce(hc2 indusid, dfadjust)--- 2001 --- N = 103, R² = 0.0237
| Robust HC2
delta2001 | Coefficient std. err. t P>|t| [95% conf. interval]
-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------
ntrgap | -.0612112 .0401833 -1.52 0.136 -.1426751 .0202527
_cons | -.0141423 .0129623 -1.09 0.283 -.0404511 .0121665
--- 2002 --- N = 103, R² = 0.1263
ntrgap | -.2598747 .0754512 -3.44 0.001 -.4128374 -.106912
_cons | -.0550989 .0220561 -2.50 0.017 -.0998649 -.0103329
--- 2004 --- N = 103, R² = 0.0857
ntrgap | -.5397825 .1527447 -3.53 0.001 -.8494428 -.2301222
_cons | -.0868008 .0524821 -1.65 0.107 -.1933207 .019719
--- 2005 --- N = 103, R² = 0.0707
ntrgap | -.5317591 .1666765 -3.19 0.003 -.8696635 -.1938548
_cons | -.1056161 .0536739 -1.97 0.057 -.2145548 .0033227
library(haven); library(sandwich); library(lmtest); library(dfadjust)
load(url("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.RData")); df <- as.data.frame(df)
for (yr in c(2001, 2002, 2004, 2005)) {
fit <- lm(as.formula(paste0("delta", yr, " ~ ntrgap")), data = df)
res <- dfadjustSE(fit)
est <- coef(fit)
se <- sqrt(diag(res$vcov)) # HC2
dfs <- res$coefficients[, "df"] # df de Bell-McCaffrey
t <- est / se
tab <- cbind(Estimate = est, `Std. Error` = se, `t value` = t,
`Pr(>|t|)` = 2 * pt(-abs(t), dfs))
cat("\n---", yr, "--- N =", nobs(fit), ", R² =", round(summary(fit)$r.squared, 5), "\n")
printCoefmat(tab, digits = 7, P.values = TRUE, has.Pvalue = TRUE)
}--- 2001 --- N = 103, R² = 0.02366
Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
(Intercept) -0.0141423 0.0129623 -1.0910 0.2827
ntrgap -0.0612112 0.0401833 -1.5233 0.1363
--- 2002 --- N = 103, R² = 0.12631
(Intercept) -0.0550989 0.0220561 -2.4981 0.0173
ntrgap -0.2598747 0.0754512 -3.4443 0.0015
--- 2004 --- N = 103, R² = 0.08567
(Intercept) -0.0868008 0.0524821 -1.6539 0.1070
ntrgap -0.5397825 0.1527447 -3.5339 0.0011
--- 2005 --- N = 103, R² = 0.07072
(Intercept) -0.1056161 0.0536739 -1.9677 0.0570
ntrgap -0.5317591 0.1666765 -3.1904 0.0029
import pandas as pd
import statsmodels.api as sm
df = pd.read_parquet("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.parquet")
for year in [2001, 2002, 2004, 2005]:
y = df[f'delta{year}']
X = sm.add_constant(df['ntrgap'])
res = sm.OLS(y, X).fit(cov_type='HC2')
print(f"--- {year} --- N = {int(res.nobs)}, R² = {res.rsquared:.5f}")
print(f" {'Variable':<10} {'Coef':>15} {'Std.Err':>12} {'t':>10} {'P>|t|':>10}")
for name in res.params.index:
print(f" {name:<10} {res.params[name]:>15.7f} {res.bse[name]:>12.7f} {res.tvalues[name]:>10.3f} {res.pvalues[name]:>10.4f}")
print()--- 2001 --- N = 103, R² = 0.02366
Variable Coef Std.Err t P>|t|
const -0.0141423 0.0129623 -1.091 0.2753
ntrgap -0.0612112 0.0401833 -1.523 0.1277
--- 2002 --- N = 103, R² = 0.12631
const -0.0550989 0.0220561 -2.498 0.0125
ntrgap -0.2598747 0.0754512 -3.444 0.0006
--- 2004 --- N = 103, R² = 0.08567
const -0.0868008 0.0524821 -1.654 0.0981
ntrgap -0.5397825 0.1527447 -3.534 0.0004
--- 2005 --- N = 103, R² = 0.07072
const -0.1056161 0.0536739 -1.968 0.0491
ntrgap -0.5317591 0.1666765 -3.190 0.0014
Interpretation: The NTR gap has no significant effect on manufacturing employment growth in 2001, but a significant negative effect from 2002 onward. The effect grows until 2004 and then stabilizes: a 10 pp larger NTR gap is associated with roughly 2.6 pp lower employment growth by 2002 and about 5.4 pp lower employment growth by 2004–2005.
CQ#37: Decompose TWFE Weights
Use
twowayfeweightswithtype(fdTR)to assess whether \(\hat{\beta}_{fe}\) estimates a convex combination of effects.
* ssc install twowayfeweights, replace
copy "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta" "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", replace
use "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", clear
twowayfeweights delta2001 indusid cons ntrgap ntrgap, type(fdTR)Under the common trends assumption,
the TWFE coefficient beta, equal to -0.0612, estimates a weighted sum of 103 ATTs.
62 ATTs receive a positive weight, and 41 receive a negative weight.
------------------------------------------------
Treat. var: ntrgap # ATTs Σ weights
------------------------------------------------
Positive weights 62 1.3190
Negative weights 41 -0.3190
------------------------------------------------
Total 103 1.0000
------------------------------------------------
library(haven); library(TwoWayFEWeights)
load(url("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.RData")); df <- as.data.frame(df)
# Workaround: fdTR with constant time variable crashes in R.
# Create a 2-period panel and use feTR (equivalent with T=2).
df_panel <- rbind(
data.frame(indusid = df$indusid, time = 1, Y = 0, D = 0),
data.frame(indusid = df$indusid, time = 2, Y = df$delta2001, D = df$ntrgap)
)
gq2 <- twowayfeweights(df_panel, "Y", "indusid", "time", "D",
type = "feTR", summary_measures = TRUE)Under the common trends assumption,
the TWFE coefficient beta, equal to -0.0612, estimates a weighted sum of 103 ATTs.
62 ATTs receive a positive weight, and 41 receive a negative weight.
Treat. var: D ATTs Σ weights
Positive weights 62 1.319
Negative weights 41 -0.319
Total 103 1
Summary Measures:
min σ(Δ) compatible with β_fe and Δ_TR = 0: 0.0317
min σ(Δ) compatible with opposite sign: 0.0642
# pip install twowayfeweights (install from the authors' repository)
import pandas as pd
from twowayfeweights import twowayfeweights
df = pd.read_parquet("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.parquet")
df["cons"] = 1
df["ntrgap_D0"] = df["ntrgap"]
result = twowayfeweights(df, "delta2001", "indusid", "cons", "ntrgap",
type="fdTR", D0="ntrgap_D0")
print(result)Under the common trends assumption,
the TWFE coefficient beta, equal to -0.0612, estimates a weighted sum of 103 ATTs.
62 ATTs receive a positive weight, and 41 receive a negative weight.
------------------------------------------------
Treat. var: ntrgap # ATTs Σ weights
------------------------------------------------
Positive weights 62 1.3190
Negative weights 41 -0.3190
------------------------------------------------
Total 103 1.0000
------------------------------------------------
Interpretation: 41 out of 103 industry ATTs receive negative weights, summing to −0.3190. The TWFE estimator does not estimate a convex combination of effects.
CQ#38: Test Random Assignment of Treatment Dose
Regress the NTR gap on pre-treatment employment levels (1997–2000) and test their joint significance.
copy "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta" "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", replace
use "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", clear
reg ntrgap lemp1997 lemp1998 lemp1999 lemp2000, vce(hc2 indusid, dfadjust)
test lemp1997 lemp1998 lemp1999 lemp2000 | Robust HC2
ntrgap | Coefficient std. err. t P>|t| [95% conf. interval]
-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------
lemp1997 | -.0219594 .1325814 -0.17 0.876 -.3877955 .3438767
lemp1998 | .6043265 .3103595 1.95 0.069 -.0534594 1.262112
lemp1999 | -.2260641 .4573776 -0.49 0.626 -1.172624 .7204955
lemp2000 | -.3418326 .2938878 -1.16 0.256 -.9476972 .264032
_cons | .1204804 .1396417 0.86 0.394 -.1628409 .4038018
F(4, 98) = 2.39 Prob > F = 0.0557
library(haven); library(car); library(sandwich); library(lmtest)
load(url("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.RData")); df <- as.data.frame(df)
m3 <- lm(ntrgap ~ lemp1997 + lemp1998 + lemp1999 + lemp2000, data = df)
coeftest(m3, vcov = vcovHC(m3, type = "HC2"))
linearHypothesis(m3, c("lemp1997=0","lemp1998=0","lemp1999=0","lemp2000=0"),
vcov. = vcovHC(m3, type = "HC2")) Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
(Intercept) 0.1204804 0.1396417 0.8628 0.3904
lemp1997 -0.0219594 0.1325814 -0.1656 0.8688
lemp1998 0.6043265 0.3103595 1.9472 0.0544
lemp1999 -0.2260641 0.4573776 -0.4943 0.6222
lemp2000 -0.3418326 0.2938878 -1.1631 0.2476
F(4, 98) = 2.3901 Pr(>F) = 0.05597
import pandas as pd
import statsmodels.api as sm
df = pd.read_parquet("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.parquet")
X_vars = ['lemp1997', 'lemp1998', 'lemp1999', 'lemp2000']
y = df['ntrgap']
X = sm.add_constant(df[X_vars])
res = sm.OLS(y, X).fit(cov_type='HC2')
print(f" {'Variable':<10} {'Coef':>15} {'Std.Err':>12} {'t':>10} {'P>|t|':>10}")
for name in res.params.index:
print(f" {name:<10} {res.params[name]:>15.7f} {res.bse[name]:>12.7f} {res.tvalues[name]:>10.3f} {res.pvalues[name]:>10.4f}")
f_test = res.f_test("lemp1997 = lemp1998 = lemp1999 = lemp2000 = 0")
print(f"\nF({int(f_test.df_num)}, {int(f_test.df_denom)}) = {f_test.fvalue:.4f} Prob > F = {f_test.pvalue:.4f}") Variable Coef Std.Err t P>|t|
const 0.1204804 0.1396417 0.863 0.3883
lemp1997 -0.0219594 0.1325814 -0.166 0.8684
lemp1998 0.6043265 0.3103595 1.947 0.0515
lemp1999 -0.2260641 0.4573776 -0.494 0.6211
lemp2000 -0.3418326 0.2938878 -1.163 0.2448
F(4, 98) = 2.3901 Prob > F = 0.0560
Interpretation: The joint F-test yields \(p = 0.056\), marginally insignificant at 5%.
Quasi-Stayer Test
Test whether quasi-stayers exist: compute \(QS = D_{(1)} / (D_{(2)} - D_{(1)})\) where \(D_{(1)}\) and \(D_{(2)}\) are the two smallest NTR gap values.
copy "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta" "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", replace
use "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", clear
sort ntrgap
display "D(1) = " ntrgap[1]
display "D(2) = " ntrgap[2]
display "QS = " ntrgap[1]/(ntrgap[2]-ntrgap[1])D(1) = 0.0202847
D(2) = 0.0235831
QS = D(1)/(D(2)-D(1)) = 6.1498877
library(haven)
load(url("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.RData")); df <- as.data.frame(df)
ntrgap_sorted <- sort(df$ntrgap)
d1 <- ntrgap_sorted[1]; d2 <- ntrgap_sorted[2]
QS <- d1 / (d2 - d1)D(1) = 0.02028472
D(2) = 0.02358311
QS = D(1)/(D(2)-D(1)) = 6.1498877
import pandas as pd
import numpy as np
df = pd.read_parquet("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.parquet")
ntrgap_sorted = np.sort(df['ntrgap'].values)
d1, d2 = ntrgap_sorted[0], ntrgap_sorted[1]
qs = d1 / (d2 - d1)
print(f"D(1) = {d1:.8f}")
print(f"D(2) = {d2:.8f}")
print(f"QS = D(1)/(D(2)-D(1)) = {qs:.7f}")D(1) = 0.02028472
D(2) = 0.02358311
QS = D(1)/(D(2)-D(1)) = 6.1498877
Interpretation: \(QS = 6.15 < 19 = 1/\alpha - 1\) at \(\alpha = 0.05\), so we fail to reject the null that quasi-stayers exist. This supports the use of the HAD framework: the industry with the smallest NTR gap (0.020) can plausibly serve as a quasi-control group.
CQ#39: did_had Event-Study Estimates
Using the
pierce_schott_didtextbookdataset, transform the data into a panel at the industry \(\times\) year level, with industries’ log-employment and NTR gap treatment from 1997 to 2005. Then, usedid_hadto compute four event-study estimates and three pre-trend estimates.
Stata nprobust note: The current nprobust .mo files on GitHub are compiled with Stata 18. If you are using Stata 17 or earlier, did_had will fail with the error nprobust_lp_mse_dpi() not found. To fix this, run once per session:
copy "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta" "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", replace
use "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", clear
do "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nppackages/nprobust/master/stata/nprobust_functions.do"Cross-platform note: The Stata output below uses Stata 18+ with the latest did_had and nprobust, which computes a single global bandwidth (\(h^*_G = 0.147\), \(N = 21\)) matching the R output. Stata 17 users may get different bandwidths per effect due to an older nprobust version. All implementations give the same quasi-stayer test statistic (\(T = 6.1499\), \(p = 0.1399\)).
* --- Load data ----------------------------------------------------------------
copy "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta" "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", replace
use "pierce_schott_didtextbook.dta", clear
* --- Construct lemp for post-treatment years ----------------------------------
* The dataset has lemp1997-lemp2000 and delta2001, delta2002, delta2004, delta2005.
* delta20XX = lemp20XX - lemp2000, so lemp20XX = lemp2000 + delta20XX.
gen lemp2001 = lemp2000 + delta2001
gen lemp2002 = lemp2000 + delta2002
gen lemp2004 = lemp2000 + delta2004
gen lemp2005 = lemp2000 + delta2005
* --- Reshape to panel (industry × year) ---------------------------------------
reshape long lemp, i(indusid) j(year)
replace ntrgap = 0 if year <= 2000
* --- If using Stata 17 or earlier, compile nprobust from source (once) --------
* do "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nppackages/nprobust/master/stata/nprobust_functions.do"
* --- Run did_had with default (epanechnikov) kernel ---------------------------------------
did_had lemp indusid year ntrgap, effects(4) placebo(3)Effect Estimates:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Effect Estimates QUG* Test
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------
| Estimate SE LB CI UB CI N BW N in BW T p-val
-------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Effect_1 | .007268 .078676 -.2385522 .0698521 103 .1465417 21 6.149888 .1398623
Effect_2 | -.133609 .1249707 -.5802821 -.0904061 103 .1465417 21 6.149888 .1398623
Effect_3 | .0350698 .593448 -1.603513 .7227608 103 .1465417 21 6.149888 .1398623
Effect_4 | -.0217339 .6140438 -1.898538 .5084691 103 .1465417 21 6.149888 .1398623
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*Quasi-untreated group
Placebo Estimates:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Placebo Estimates
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Estimate SE LB CI UB CI N BW N in BW
-------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Placebo_1 | -.0198445 .1299684 -.3713658 .1381008 103 .1465417 21
Placebo_2 | -.0565281 .2451583 -.4107375 .5502655 103 .1465417 21
Placebo_3 | -.1213829 .1814087 -.3864638 .3246453 103 .1465417 21
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
library(haven)
library(tidyr)
library(dplyr)
library(DIDHAD) # devtools::install_github("chaisemartinPackages/did_had/R")
library(nprobust) # install.packages("nprobust")
load(url("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.RData")); df <- as.data.frame(df)
# --- Construct lemp for post-treatment years ----------------------------------
df$lemp2001 <- df$lemp2000 + df$delta2001
df$lemp2002 <- df$lemp2000 + df$delta2002
df$lemp2004 <- df$lemp2000 + df$delta2004
df$lemp2005 <- df$lemp2000 + df$delta2005
# --- Reshape to panel (industry × year) ---------------------------------------
lemp_cols <- grep("^lemp[0-9]+$", names(df), value = TRUE)
df_long <- df %>%
select(indusid, ntrgap, all_of(lemp_cols)) %>%
pivot_longer(
cols = all_of(lemp_cols),
names_to = "year", names_prefix = "lemp",
values_to = "lemp"
) %>%
mutate(
year = as.integer(year),
ntrgap = ifelse(year <= 2000, 0, ntrgap)
) %>%
as.data.frame()
# --- Run did_had with triangular kernel ---------------------------------------
options(digits = 7)
result <- did_had(
df = df_long,
outcome = "lemp",
group = "indusid",
time = "year",
treatment = "ntrgap",
effects = 4,
placebo = 3,
kernel = "tri",
graph_off = TRUE
)
summary(result)Effect Estimates:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Effect Estimates QUG* Test
---------------------------------------------------- ---------------
Estimate SE LB.CI UB.CI N BW N.BW T p.val
Effect_1 0.0072700 0.0787500 -0.2387000 0.0700000 103 0.1465400 21 6.1498900 0.1398600
Effect_2 -0.1336100 0.1250000 -0.5803500 -0.0903400 103 0.1465400 21 6.1498900 0.1398600
Effect_3 0.0350700 0.5934600 -1.6035300 0.7227800 103 0.1465400 21 6.1498900 0.1398600
Effect_4 -0.0217300 0.6140600 -1.8985800 0.5085100 103 0.1465400 21 6.1498900 0.1398600
*Quasi-Untreated Group
Placebo Estimates:
------------------------------------------------------------
Placebo Estimates
--------------------------------------------------
Estimate SE LB.CI UB.CI N BW N.BW
Placebo_1 -0.0266300 0.1328800 -0.3772700 0.1436200 103 0.1506800 21
Placebo_2 -0.0474400 0.2568500 -0.4426400 0.5641900 103 0.1465400 21
Placebo_3 -0.1147700 0.1851600 -0.3988900 0.3269400 103 0.1465400 21
# pip install did-had>=0.2.1
import pandas as pd
from did_had import DidHad
df = pd.read_parquet("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Credible-Answers/did_book/main/cc_xd_didtextbook_2025_9_30/Data%20sets/Pierce%20and%20Schott%202016/pierce_schott_didtextbook.parquet")
# Build panel from wide to long
rows = []
for _, r in df.iterrows():
base = r['lemp2000']
ind = r['indusid']
ntr = r['ntrgap']
for yr in [1997, 1998, 1999]:
rows.append({'indusid': ind, 'year': yr, 'lemp': base + r[f'delta{yr}'], 'ntrgap': 0.0})
rows.append({'indusid': ind, 'year': 2000, 'lemp': base, 'ntrgap': 0.0})
for yr in [2001, 2002, 2004, 2005]:
rows.append({'indusid': ind, 'year': yr, 'lemp': base + r[f'delta{yr}'], 'ntrgap': ntr})
panel = pd.DataFrame(rows)
model = DidHad(kernel='tri')
results = model.fit(
df=panel, outcome='lemp', group='indusid',
time='year', treatment='ntrgap', effects=4, placebo=3)
print(results)===========================================================================
DID-HAD Estimation Results
===========================================================================
Number of groups: 103
Number of periods: 8
Adoption period (F): 2001
Kernel: tri
Confidence level: 95%
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Effect Estimates QUG* Test
--------------------------------------------------- ---------------
Estimate SE LB.CI UB.CI N BW N.BW T p.val
Effect_1 0.00727 0.07875 -0.23870 0.07000 103 0.14654 21 6.14989 0.13986
Effect_2 -0.13361 0.12500 -0.58035 -0.09034 103 0.14654 21 6.14989 0.13986
Effect_3 0.03507 0.59346 -1.60353 0.72278 103 0.14654 21 6.14989 0.13986
Effect_4 -0.02173 0.61406 -1.89858 0.50851 103 0.14654 21 6.14989 0.13986
*Quasi-Untreated Group
--------------------------------------------------------------
Placebo Estimates
----------------------------------------------------
Estimate SE LB.CI UB.CI N BW N.BW
Placebo_1 -0.02663 0.13288 -0.37727 0.14362 103 0.15068 21
Placebo_2 -0.04744 0.25685 -0.44264 0.56419 103 0.14654 21
Placebo_3 -0.11477 0.18516 -0.39889 0.32694 103 0.14654 21
===========================================================================
Interpretation: The quasi-stayer test is not rejected (\(T = 6.15\), \(p = 0.140\)): 21 industries with an NTR gap below 14.7 percentage points serve as quasi-controls. The R output shows the optimal bandwidth \(h^*_G = 0.147\), matching the PDF textbook. The estimated event-study effect at 2002 (Effect_2) is negative and significant in both platforms, while the remaining effects and all three pre-trends are insignificant. Confidence intervals are wide: with only 103 industries, the non-parametric estimator \(\widehat{WATT}^{qs}_{h^*_G}\) is imprecise. Pre-trends are not significant, but they are also imprecise — by extrapolating a linear trend from the upper bound of the 1999 pre-trend CI to the origin, differential trends could account for the estimated effects.